At a glance
- Approved, with conditions, a new home at 105 NE Pine St., at the corner of First Street and Highway 99. Vote: 4–1.
- Conditions: Dutch-hip roof ends with shake siding and gable-end vents, simple decorative elements in the gables, and smooth Dutch-lap siding elsewhere.
- Agreed to post design-review applications on the commission's Facebook page, with comments turned off.
- Thomas Hotel: no new application from the owner; the commission says its hands are tied until it gets structural information.
- Next regular meeting: Monday, Oct. 26, 6 p.m., Council Chambers. Agenda: tightening the design-review ordinance.
Oakland Historic Preservation Commission, special meeting, October 15, 2026
A new house will go up at the gateway to Oakland's historic district, but not before the city's Historic Preservation Commission redrew part of its roofline.
Meeting in special session Thursday, the commission approved plans by Avery Building for a single-story home at 105 NE Pine St., on the corner of First Street and Highway 99. The approval came with conditions: the home's hip-roof ends will become Dutch hips, finished with shake siding and gable-end vents and some simple decorative trim in the gables. The rest of the house will be clad in smooth Dutch-lap siding rather than the wood-grain fiber cement common on new homes. The vote was 4–1.
It was the project's second appearance before the commission. On Sept. 30, commissioners tabled the application and asked the builder to make the house more visually compatible with its historic neighbors.
What changed
Builder Craig Avery came back with a list of revisions. He narrowed the siding reveal from the seven inches typical of new homes to four or five inches, closer to old clapboard. He beefed up the trim to "mimic the old big timbers," added detail around the windows, kept the shutters, chose more traditional lighting and offered five period color schemes. He also added a front dormer to break up the long roofline and suggest a second story.
"We're all trying to reach the same goal here," Avery told the commission: "to build a home, meet the criteria, and also give it a historical appearance."
The plans show a covered front porch six feet deep, a carport at the rear, a privacy fence along the back of the lot and a white picket fence across the front toward First Street.
"Right there on 99"
Commissioner Gordon Forbes said the revisions still left what read as a ranch house at the most visible spot in the district.
"This looks great in a Sutherlin subdivision," he said. "I'm just having a problem with it being right there on 99." He warned that other vacant lots nearby could follow the same pattern.
Two neighbors made the same case in writing. In a letter received by the city Oct. 2, Betty Tamm and Geoff Faraghan of Oak Street said the homes around the lot share elements such as one-and-a-half or two stories, gambrel or steep gable roofs, porches with columns and double-hung windows. They said the proposal "looks like a 1970's ranch home" and asked the commission to require at least a story and a half plus three or four of those features.
The commission did not require a taller house. Instead, after some back-and-forth with the builder over rooflines, it settled on the Dutch-hip ends, which rise from a hip into a small gable, as a way to add the steeper, gabled look of nearby homes without rebuilding the design. Avery agreed to the changes at the table.
Commissioners first voted on the roof changes, then realized the motion had left out the siding and voted again on an amended motion that added it. Gordon Forbes voted no both times, though he thanked the builder. "I'm much less against it than I was when we first sat down," he said.
A rule that's "too gray"
The debate exposed a problem commissioners said they need to fix. The builder had met the specific items listed in the city's design-review ordinance, Ordinance 456, one commissioner noted, and asked what gave the commission the right to demand more. Another said the trouble lies in the ordinance's more subjective language about complementing surrounding buildings.
"I think it's too gray," she said. "It's not detailed."
The commission plans to begin work on clearer ordinance language at its next meeting.
Before the meeting closed, a member of the audience read the National Register inventory's description of the building that once stood on the lot: a one-and-a-half-story wood-frame house moved from Old Town, with shiplap siding, a cross-gable roof, a central chimney and six-over-six sash windows.
Applications go online
Commissioners agreed to post design-review applications on the commission's Facebook page, facebook.com/ohpcoregon. Until now, notices have been posted only at City Hall and the post office. Comments will be turned off on each post, since the commission cannot take public comment there. Commissioners said they would also like to post applications on the city's website once it is rebuilt.
Thomas Hotel: still stalled
Under audience concerns, Conni Westford Riley asked where things stand with the Thomas Hotel. "Unfortunately, nothing is going on," the chair, Rob Pike, replied.
The commission denied the owner's original application and has not received a new one, the chair said. According to the chair, the city has sent the owner a letter requiring a structural engineer's assessment of the building, and the owner could face fines of up to $250 a day if he does not respond. "Until we get any of that kind of information, our hands are tied," the chair said.
Commissioners noted that neither the commission nor the city can raise money for the building or buy it. Conni Westford Riley said she has started a GoFundMe for people willing to help buy the property if the owner will sell, and that an offer to buy it has gone unanswered. One commissioner said a structural engineer from Camas Valley has offered to look at the building.
The hotel's history may help its case. Conni Westford Riley said her research shows Sarah Thomas survived the Lost Wagon Train of 1853, which could strengthen the building's claim for preservation funding. State funding, commissioners noted, is likely years away.
The commission's next regular meeting is Monday, Oct. 26, at 6 p.m. in Council Chambers, 637 NE Locust St.